SiftMac
Features · Updated 21 November 2026

A verdict for every item: does it come back?

By Mohit Nippanikar, who makes SiftMac

The short answer
On this page
  1. How the verdicts work
  2. Why every item gets one
  3. What a verdict doesn’t do
  4. Questions

1. How the verdicts work

Each verdict answers one question about an item: if it’s removed, does it come back? The badge sits next to every item and every category in the Detailed view. Click an item and the panel on the right repeats the verdict with a reason in plain words, a Comes back? line, and where the item lives.

BadgeWhat it meansComes back?Examples
SafeNothing is lost. The app makes a fresh copy if it ever needs one.Yes, on its ownApp caches, logs older than a week, temp files from apps that have quit, copies of attachments you opened in Mail
RebuildsComes back, but has to be downloaded or built again.Yes, by downloading or building againHomebrew, pip and other package caches, node_modules in old projects, Xcode DerivedData, iPhone update files
You decideCan’t be brought back once it’s gone, so the choice is yours.Only from the Undo Shelf, for mostOld downloads, unused apps, iPhone backups, old AI chats, large files, the Trash
In useAn open app or running program is using it.Not removedA cache folder while its app is open
LockedmacOS won’t let SiftMac move it without an administrator, or macOS or another app manages it.Not removedAn app an administrator installed, Apple Intelligence models, purgeable space

The Comes back? line gets specific where it can: “Yes, when you install again” for node_modules, “Yes, when you build again” for build output, “Yes, when you plug it in” for the symbols Xcode copies from a device, and “You keep the other copy” for a duplicate.

SiftMac’s Detailed view: each category with a Safe or You decide badge, a size bar and its size, under a dial showing what’s picked to free up

Where a verdict comes from

2. Why every item gets one

When a Mac fills up, the useful question about any folder is what happens after it’s gone. A cache comes back by itself. A Python environment comes back when you run pip install. An iPhone backup doesn’t come back at all. One total and one button hide that difference, and that’s where cleanups go wrong.

Putting the answer next to each item lets you skim the safe parts and slow down on the rest. It also sets the defaults: caches, logs, temp files, old downloads and the Trash start ticked, while apps, duplicates, large files, developer and AI files, Mail and Messages attachments and System Data wait for you to tick them.

To see a verdict without installing anything, paste a folder into the Does it come back? checker, which runs the same notes in your browser.

3. What a verdict doesn’t do

Questions

What’s the difference between Safe and Rebuilds?

Both come back. Safe items come back on their own with nothing for you to do, like an app’s cache. Rebuilds items come back only when something downloads or builds them again, like a package cache or a project’s node_modules, which takes time and bandwidth.

Does “You decide” mean SiftMac thinks I should delete it?

No. It means the item can’t come back by itself once it’s gone, so it’s your call. Most of these start unticked, and most that you remove wait on the Undo Shelf for 7 days first.

Why is a duplicate marked Safe?

Because an identical copy stays where it is, so removing the extra one loses nothing. It still starts unticked and goes onto the Undo Shelf, and if the kept copy moves or changes before you clean, the extra one is kept too.

Why does an item say In use when I’m not using the app?

Something from that app is running, perhaps only a background helper, or the folder is shared by one maker’s apps: with Chrome open, Google’s whole cache folder counts as in use. Quit the app and check again (⌘R) to include it.

Do the verdicts need an internet connection?

No. They come from SiftMac’s own rules and notes, on your Mac. Nothing about your files is sent anywhere to be judged.

How SiftMac handles it. Every item in the Detailed view carries its verdict, a reason in plain words and a Comes back? line, and you can untick anything before you press Clean up. Scanning and reading the verdicts are free.

Download SiftMac · scanning is free, and so is your first 2 GB of cleaning · See how it works