Mail and Messages attachments: which come back, and which don’t
- By account and by year. SiftMac lists the attachments Mail saved for each account, the copies Mail made of attachments you opened, and Messages photos, videos and files of 5 MB or more, a year at a time.
- It knows which come back: attachments from IMAP, Exchange, iCloud or Gmail accounts download again from the server; ones from a POP account or On My Mac may be the only copy.
- Names, sizes and dates only. SiftMac never reads an email or a message, and everything you remove waits on the Undo Shelf.
1. How it works
macOS keeps Mail and Messages private, so this category needs Full Disk Access: one switch in System Settings › Privacy & Security covers both. Until it’s on, the category explains how to turn it on, in three steps, and notices when you have.
- Attachments, per account. In Mail’s newest store, like
~/Library/Mail/V10, every Attachments folder in an account’s mailboxes is gathered into one item named after the account, with the number of files. Mailboxes kept On My Mac are an item of their own. - Where each account keeps its mail. SiftMac reads each account’s type from macOS’s accounts list, read-only. IMAP, Exchange, Google, Yahoo, AOL and iCloud accounts keep every attachment on the server, so their items are Rebuilds: opening the email downloads it again. POP accounts and On My Mac may hold the only copy, so they’re You decide, and so is any account SiftMac can’t identify.
- Attachments you opened. When you open or preview an attachment, Mail saves a copy in
Mail Downloads. The original stays in the email, so this item is Safe.
Messages
In ~/Library/Messages/Attachments, every file of 5 MB or more is grouped by its year, with how many are videos, photos and other files: “Messages attachments from 2023”. Smaller ones aren’t listed, because they add up to little and every one removed leaves an empty bubble in its chat. Messages items are You decide.
While Mail or Messages is open, its items are In use and stay. None of this category is ticked until you tick it, and everything you remove from it, Mail or Messages, goes onto the Undo Shelf first.
2. Why it’s worth a look
Mail and Messages keep a copy of what people send you, out of sight in your Library. Years of photo and video threads, and the attachments Mail has downloaded along the way, add up without ever showing in Finder.
The question that matters for each attachment is the one SiftMac asks everywhere: does it come back? For a Gmail or iCloud account, yes, from the server. For a POP account, maybe not at all. Showing that per account, before anything moves, is the difference between an easy clean-up and losing the only copy of a file someone once sent you.
3. What it doesn’t do
- It doesn’t delete emails or conversations. Only attachment files go. In Messages, a removed photo or video shows as missing in its bubble until you put it back.
- It doesn’t read them either. SiftMac looks at names, sizes and dates, never at the text of an email or a message.
- Small Messages attachments stay. Anything under 5 MB isn’t listed.
- Rebuilds assumes the email is still on the server. An attachment downloads again only from an email that still exists there.
- It doesn’t change Messages’ settings. To stop attachments piling up, set Messages › Settings › Keep messages yourself.
- It can’t see anything without Full Disk Access. The category stays locked until it’s on.
Questions
Will removing Mail attachments delete my emails?
No. Only the attachment files Mail saved on your Mac go. For server accounts, opening the email downloads the attachment again; for POP and On My Mac, the attachment may be the only copy, which is why those are You decide.
How does SiftMac know an account keeps attachments on the server?
It reads the account type from macOS’s list of accounts, read-only. IMAP, Exchange, iCloud, Google, Yahoo and AOL accounts keep mail on the server; POP accounts keep it on the Mac.
What happens in Messages after I remove attachments?
The messages stay, but those photos and videos show as missing in their bubbles. Put them back from the Undo Shelf within 7 days to restore them; Messages in iCloud may also keep a copy.
Does SiftMac read my email?
No. It reads file names, sizes and dates in Mail’s and Messages’ attachment folders, plus each account’s type. It never opens an email or a message.
How SiftMac handles it. Mail & Messages attachments lists Mail’s saved attachments by account, with whether the server keeps them, and big Messages files by year, all unticked. With Full Disk Access on, it reads names, sizes and dates only, and anything you remove waits on the Undo Shelf for 7 days.
Download SiftMac · scanning is free, and so is your first 2 GB of cleaning · See how it works