Honest sizes: only the space you really get back
- Only what comes back is counted. Every size in the categories SiftMac finds is what removing that item really frees, not the size Finder shows for it.
- Shared space is left out: blocks a file shares with an APFS clone elsewhere, and files still linked from somewhere else, stay on the disk after removal, so SiftMac doesn’t count them.
- What it means for you: sometimes a smaller number than you expected, but one that matches the space you get back.
1. How SiftMac measures
On APFS, the file system every Mac running macOS 14 uses for its startup disk, two files can share the same blocks. A copy made with Finder’s Duplicate or cp -c is a clone: it looks like a second full file but takes almost no extra space until one of them changes. A hard link is one file with two names. In both cases, deleting one of them gives back little or nothing.
So for every file it might remove, SiftMac asks macOS for the file’s private size: the bytes that belong to it alone and aren’t shared with any clone. That, not the file’s length, is what gets added up. Where a disk can’t answer, such as one that isn’t APFS, it falls back to the space the file takes on disk.
- Clones: only a file’s own blocks count. A clone whose blocks all live on in the original counts as nothing.
- Hard links: a file with several links counts once, and only when every one of its links is in what’s being removed. If a link survives elsewhere, removing the file frees nothing, so it isn’t counted.
- Symlinks aren’t followed, so files they point to are never measured or removed through them.
- Units are decimal, like Finder’s: 1 GB is 1,000,000,000 bytes.
The rule runs through every list. Files that are clones or hard links of each other aren’t listed as duplicates, because removing one frees nothing. An Ollama model is sized by the layers no other model uses, and removed with ollama rm so shared layers stay. Something in the Trash that shares its space with a copy says so: “shares its space with a copy, so removing it frees nothing”. And if a cleanup fails part-way through a folder, only what was really removed is counted in the result and on the Receipt.
To keep a check quick despite the extra care, SiftMac reads a whole folder’s names, link counts and private sizes in one system call, and spreads folders across up to eight cores.
2. Why it matters
Clones are common on a Mac without anyone making them on purpose. Finder makes one every time you duplicate a file on the same disk, and so can apps that copy files. A folder of copies can look huge and free almost nothing. A cleaner that adds up file lengths promises space that never arrives, and you’re left wondering why the disk is still full.
Counting honestly also stops you giving up a file for nothing. When removing an item would free no space, SiftMac doesn’t offer it. The one exception is the Trash: an item there still goes when you clean the Trash, because you’d already thrown it away.
You can see the difference on your own Mac. Duplicate a large file in Finder and move the copy to the Trash. Get Info still shows the copy’s full size; SiftMac’s Trash list shows it freeing 0 KB, and says why.
3. Where sizes can still differ
- The space map and Search show space on disk per file. Two clones of one file both show their full size there. The categories a check fills are the ones that count shared space once.
- Some sizes come from their owner. Docker’s numbers come from
docker system df, and purgeable space from what macOS reports; SiftMac can’t measure inside Docker’s disk image. - Shelved space isn’t free yet. What goes onto the Undo Shelf keeps its space until the cleanup expires or you empty the shelf, so your free space grows in two steps.
- Free space moves on its own. SiftMac’s free-space figure is the one macOS gives for important use, which counts purgeable space as available, and macOS frees purgeable space by itself when it needs to.
- Hard links are matched within one item. If two separate items each hold a link to the same file, neither counts it, even if you remove both.
Questions
Why does SiftMac show a smaller size than Finder?
Finder shows how big a file is. SiftMac shows how much space removing it gives back. For a clone, or a file with another hard link, those are very different numbers.
What is an APFS clone?
A copy that shares its blocks with the original instead of duplicating them. It takes almost no space until you change one of the two files, and then only the changed parts take new space. On APFS disks, Finder’s Duplicate makes one.
Why does something in my Trash free nothing?
It shares its space with a copy that’s still on your Mac, so removing it gives none back. SiftMac still lets you clear it, since you’d already put it in the Trash.
Does SiftMac list clones as duplicates?
No. Files that are clones or hard links of each other share their space, so removing one would free nothing. Only copies that take real space of their own are listed.
How SiftMac handles it. Every size in SiftMac’s categories is what removing that item really frees, worked out from APFS private sizes and hard-link counts, and items that would free nothing aren’t offered. The total you see before cleaning is built from those numbers.
Download SiftMac · scanning is free, and so is your first 2 GB of cleaning · See how it works