OnyX vs CleanMyMac: free maintenance or a paid all-in-one
- Choose OnyX for free, hands-on control of macOS maintenance: verifying system files, rebuilding indexes, clearing caches and changing hidden settings, one task at a time.
- Choose CleanMyMac for guided cleanup with a disk map, duplicates, an uninstaller and malware removal, and similar maintenance tasks behind a Scan button, from $3.33 a month billed yearly.
- If your disk is full, OnyX won’t show what fills it. CleanMyMac’s Space Lens will, and so will a tool built only for that, such as SiftMac.
1. OnyX and CleanMyMac side by side
Read on titanium-software.fr, cleanmymac.com and MacPaw’s store and help pages on 20 November 2026.
| OnyX | CleanMyMac | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free, donations welcome | $3.33 a month and up, billed yearly; also monthly or one-time |
| Model | Free; a separate version for each macOS | Subscription or one-time licence |
| What it does | Verifies system files, runs cleaning and maintenance tasks, rebuilds databases and indexes, deletes caches, uninstalls apps, changes Finder, Dock and Safari settings | Guided cleanup, malware scans, an uninstaller and updater, duplicates, the Space Lens disk map, cloud cleanup, and maintenance tasks |
| Maintenance tasks | Its core job, chosen one by one | Flush DNS, free purgeable space and RAM, periodic scripts, reindex Spotlight, repair disk permissions, speed up Mail, thin Time Machine snapshots (not in the App Store edition) |
| Shows what fills the disk | Not part of its description | Yes, Space Lens and My Clutter |
| How it deletes | Deletes the caches and other items you tick | Permanently for large and old files and for duplicates, per MacPaw’s help |
| Undo | No undo described | No undo described |
| Explains items | Not described on its site | Smart Insights explains files where Apple Intelligence is on (Apple silicon, macOS 26) |
| Platforms | 5.1.2 for macOS 27 (Apple silicon); 5.0.6 for Tahoe 26; older versions back to Mac OS X 10.2 | macOS 11 or later, one app across versions; MacPaw Store, Setapp, App Store |
| Made by | Titanium Software, since 2003 | MacPaw, since 2008 |
2. How they really differ
Who decides what runs
OnyX lays the controls out and lets you pick each task and setting, which suits people who know what rebuilding a database or an index will do. CleanMyMac decides more for you: its site recommends starting with Smart Care, which runs five core actions in one go, and then exploring the separate modules.
Where they overlap
Both clear caches and run housekeeping. CleanMyMac’s list covers flushing the DNS cache, freeing purgeable space and RAM, the periodic scripts, a Spotlight reindex, repairing disk permissions, speeding up Mail and thinning Time Machine snapshots. MacPaw’s help notes that the Mac App Store edition can’t run those tasks; the MacPaw Store and Setapp editions can. Apple adds that macOS clears caches and logs that are safe to delete by itself when space is needed, so neither app is needed for routine cache clearing.
What only one of them does
CleanMyMac adds what OnyX’s description doesn’t include: malware removal, a disk map, duplicates and similar images, app updates and cleanup of cloud drives such as iCloud Drive and Dropbox. OnyX, for its part, verifies the structure of system files and exposes settings for the Finder, the Dock, Safari and other Apple apps, which aren’t on CleanMyMac’s feature list.
Keeping up with macOS
OnyX makes a version for each macOS and says not to use one meant for an earlier system; older versions are no longer updated, and the current one needs Apple silicon. CleanMyMac is one app for macOS 11 and later, updated in place.
3. Which one to choose
Pick OnyX if
- you’re troubleshooting and know which index, cache or database you want to rebuild;
- you want the hidden Finder, Dock and Safari settings;
- you won’t pay for maintenance you can run yourself.
Pick CleanMyMac if
- you’d rather run one scan than choose tasks;
- you also want malware removal, a disk map, duplicates and app updates;
- you want one app that keeps working across macOS updates.
You can also keep OnyX for the odd repair and use something else for space. For that half, see the OnyX alternatives.
Questions
Is OnyX a free alternative to CleanMyMac?
For maintenance, partly: both clear caches, reindex Spotlight and run housekeeping tasks. OnyX doesn’t remove malware, map your disk, find duplicates or update apps, which are much of what CleanMyMac charges for.
Is OnyX really free?
Yes. Titanium Software has made it since 2003 so that all Mac users can use it freely, and asks for donations instead of a price.
Do I need to run maintenance tasks at all?
Not as a routine. Apple says macOS clears caches and logs that are safe to delete when space is needed. Run a task for a reason, such as a Spotlight reindex when search stops finding files you know are there.
Can CleanMyMac’s App Store version run OnyX-style tasks?
No. MacPaw’s help lists the maintenance tasks, from flushing the DNS cache to reindexing Spotlight, as available in the MacPaw Store and Setapp editions only.
How SiftMac handles it. SiftMac does one job neither app is built around: freeing space with a reason for every item. It shows what fills your disk, says whether each item comes back, skips what’s in use, and keeps downloads, apps, duplicates and the Trash on the Undo Shelf for 7 days. No maintenance scripts, no settings changes; $12 once for the first 100 buyers.
Download SiftMac · scanning is free, and so is your first 2 GB of cleaning · See how it works