SiftMac
Compare · Checked 20 November 2026 · Updated 21 November 2026

CleanMyMac vs MacKeeper: two Mac all-in-ones compared

By Mohit Nippanikar, who makes SiftMac

The short answer
On this page
  1. CleanMyMac and MacKeeper side by side
  2. The differences that matter
  3. Which one to choose
  4. Questions

1. CleanMyMac and MacKeeper side by side

Both columns come from the makers’ own sites, read on 20 November 2026. Prices are in US dollars and can differ by country.

CleanMyMacMacKeeper
PriceFrom $3.33 a month on the yearly plan for 1 Mac; plans for 2 and 5 Macs$71.40 a year for 1 Mac, $89.40 a year for 3 Macs, or $10.95 a month
ModelYearly or monthly subscription, or a one-time licenceYearly or monthly subscription, renewing automatically
Free to try7-day free trialA free download with limited use
Refunds30-day money-back guarantee30 days for yearly plans, 14 for monthly; none once a licence has been used for 6 months
What it doesCleanup, malware removal, maintenance tasks, an uninstaller and updater, duplicates, Space Lens and Cloud Cleanup: more than 25 toolsMalware scanning and real-time protection, junk and unused-app cleanup, memory cleanup, ad and pop-up blocking, a VPN, password-leak alerts, 24/7 chat
How it deletesLarge and old files and duplicates are deleted permanently, bypassing the Trash; Photos items go to Recently DeletedSafe Cleanup removes logs, caches, Trash, languages and Mail attachments, all selected by default, and asks before emptying the Trash
UndoNone described in MacPaw’s helpNone described in its help
Explains itemsSmart Insights, on Apple silicon Macs with macOS Tahoe 26 and Apple Intelligence onGroups junk by type
PlatformsmacOS 11 or later; from the MacPaw Store, Setapp or the Mac App StoremacOS 10.15 or later; from mackeeper.com
Made byMacPaw (since 2008)Clario Tech; first made by ZeoBIT

2. The differences that matter

MacKeeper goes further on security

MacKeeper is built around protection. Its subscription includes real-time virus protection, blocking of adware and pop-ups, a VPN, monitoring of your email accounts for leaked passwords, and support chat at any hour. CleanMyMac has malware removal with Quick, Normal and Deep scans and privacy tools for browsers, Wi-Fi networks and app permissions, but no VPN and no leak monitoring.

CleanMyMac goes further on cleanup

CleanMyMac’s cleanup is wider. Space Lens maps the disk, My Clutter finds duplicates, similar images and old downloads, Cloud Cleanup looks into iCloud Drive, Google Drive, OneDrive and Dropbox, and it now lists AI-tool clutter and local models. Its Performance tasks flush the DNS cache, free purgeable space, run the periodic scripts and thin Time Machine snapshots, in the MacPaw Store and Setapp editions. MacKeeper’s cleanup covers junk files, duplicates, unused apps, widgets, browser extensions and app leftovers.

How you pay, and how you leave

CleanMyMac can be bought once, as well as monthly or yearly. MacKeeper is subscription only, and emails a reminder at least 7 days before each charge. Refund rules differ: MacPaw offers 30 days on CleanMyMac, while MacKeeper allows 30 days on yearly plans and 14 on monthly ones, and nothing after six months of use. MacPaw’s store also offers CleanMyMac at 40% off to people who already use another Mac cleaner or antivirus.

History

MacKeeper’s original developer, ZeoBIT, settled a class action in 2015 by putting $2 million into a refund fund, without admitting fault; the suit had accused it of deceptive advertising. ZeoBIT had sold MacKeeper in 2013, and Clario Tech sells it today.

3. Which one to choose

Pick CleanMyMac if

Pick MacKeeper if

Or neither

If what you really want is disk space, you may not need a suite. macOS’s Storage settings and XProtect cover the basics for free, and a one-time cleaner such as SiftMac does the space part with an undo. More options are on the MacKeeper alternatives page.

Questions

Is CleanMyMac better than MacKeeper?

It depends which half you need. CleanMyMac has more cleanup tools and a one-time licence option; MacKeeper puts more into security and privacy, with real-time protection, ad blocking, a VPN and password-leak alerts.

Which one costs less?

For one Mac, CleanMyMac’s yearly plan starts at $3.33 a month, about $40 a year, against MacKeeper’s $71.40 a year. MacKeeper’s plan for three Macs was $89.40 a year. Both as listed on 20 November 2026.

Can I switch from MacKeeper to CleanMyMac for less?

MacPaw’s store offers CleanMyMac at 40% off if you use another Mac cleaner or antivirus; you request the discount from the store page. Cancel MacKeeper before its next charge, which it reminds you of at least 7 days ahead.

Do I need either one to stay safe from malware?

macOS has XProtect, which checks apps for known malware and removes it, and Gatekeeper for apps from outside the App Store. Both apps add their own scanning on top; whether that’s worth paying for is your call.

How SiftMac handles it. If what you want from either is disk space, SiftMac does only that: a verdict and a reason for every item, nothing in use touched, and downloads, apps, duplicates and the Trash kept 7 days on the Undo Shelf. $12 once for the first 100 buyers, then $19, for 2 Macs; no malware scanning or VPN.

Download SiftMac · scanning is free, and so is your first 2 GB of cleaning · See how it works