SiftMac
Compare · Checked 20 November 2026 · Updated 21 November 2026

AppCleaner vs CleanMyMac for uninstalling Mac apps

By Mohit Nippanikar, who makes SiftMac

The short answer
On this page
  1. Side by side
  2. The differences that matter
  3. Which to choose
  4. A third option: SiftMac
  5. Questions

1. Side by side

From freemacsoft.net and MacPaw’s own pages (cleanmymac.com, its store and its support guide to uninstalling), checked on 20 November 2026.

AppCleanerCleanMyMac
Made byFreeMacSoftMacPaw
PriceFree; the site asks only for donationsAnnual, monthly or one-time plans for 1, 2 or 5 Macs; from $3.33 a month
Try firstNothing to try: it’s free7-day free trial; 30-day money-back guarantee
How you uninstallDrop an app onto its window, then click the delete buttonApplications › Scan › Manage My Applications › Uninstaller; select apps, click Uninstall
Finds apps for youNo: you choose the appYes: Unused (not opened in six months), Suspicious, by store, vendor or plugin; old 32-bit apps marked
Related filesFinds the small files an app spread through your systemRemoves apps with their components, including files outside Applications
Where removed files goNot stated on its siteNot stated in MacPaw’s guide
Explains appsNoSmart Insights, on macOS Tahoe 26 or later with Apple Intelligence on
LimitsNot described on its siteCan’t remove system apps; the App Store edition can’t remove App Store apps themselves
Requirements3.7: macOS 15 or later; 3.6.8: 10.14 to 15.6; builds back to 10.10macOS 11 or later
Also doesNothing else: uninstalling only25+ tools: cleanup, malware, speed, app updates, cloud storage, duplicates, Space Lens

2. The differences that matter

You pick the app, or it finds them

AppCleaner starts from an app you name: drop it on the window, check the related files it lists, delete. CleanMyMac starts from a scan of every app. Its Applications module sorts them into groups: Unused, for apps you haven’t opened in six months; Suspicious, MacPaw’s group for apps from developers or sources in Russia and Belarus; and groups by store (App Store, Setapp, Steam), vendor and plugins. You can sort by size, name or last opened, and see each app’s total size including its resources, which helps when you don’t know where to start.

What it costs

AppCleaner is free; FreeMacSoft only asks for donations. CleanMyMac’s uninstaller comes with the suite: plans for 1, 2 or 5 Macs, paid yearly, monthly or once, from $3.33 a month on MacPaw’s store, which also offers 40% off on request if you already use another Mac cleaner or antivirus. If uninstalling is the only part you’d use, that’s a lot of app to pay for.

What happens to removed files

Neither maker says, on the pages we checked, whether removed apps and their files go to the Trash first. Look in the Trash after removing something, and keep a Time Machine backup. Apple’s own guide notes that uninstalling an app doesn’t remove documents you created with it, and that the space is only freed once the Trash is emptied.

Limits worth knowing

MacPaw says CleanMyMac can’t remove system apps, which it adds to an ignore list, and that its App Store edition can’t remove the core of App Store apps: it clears their other files and you delete the app afterwards. AppCleaner’s newest version, 3.7, needs macOS 15; on macOS 14 or earlier you use 3.6.8 or an older build from the same page.

Everything else

AppCleaner does nothing but uninstall. CleanMyMac is a suite of 25+ tools: Smart Care, junk cleanup, a malware scanner, login and background items, app updates, duplicates and similar images, Space Lens and Cloud Cleanup. Smart Insights, which explains unfamiliar apps and files, needs an Apple silicon Mac with macOS Tahoe 26 and Apple Intelligence turned on.

3. Which to choose

4. A third option: SiftMac

SiftMac does the finding CleanMyMac does, without the suite or the subscription. It lists apps nobody has opened in six months (three months to a year, your choice) with the files each keeps in your Library, removes apps you drag onto it, and notices when you trash an app yourself and offers to clear what it left. Every app and its files wait 7 days on the Undo Shelf. An app an administrator installed needs a password, which macOS asks for in its own window; SiftMac never sees it. It’s $12 once for the first 100 buyers, then $19, for 2 Macs, on macOS 14 or later. How SiftMac removes apps.

Questions

Does CleanMyMac remove apps better than AppCleaner?

Both remove an app with its related files. CleanMyMac adds groups that find candidates for you, app updates and Smart Insights; AppCleaner removes exactly what you drop on it, for free.

Is AppCleaner free?

Yes. FreeMacSoft’s site lists no price, only a donation link.

Can CleanMyMac remove App Store apps?

The version from MacPaw’s site can. MacPaw says its App Store edition can’t remove the core binaries of App Store apps; it removes their related files, and you delete the app itself afterwards.

Do I need an uninstaller at all?

Not always. Apple’s advice is to use an app’s own uninstaller if it has one, since that also removes login items and extensions, and otherwise drag the app to the Trash. An uninstaller helps with the settings and support files left behind in your Library.

How SiftMac handles it. SiftMac lists apps unopened for six months with their Library files, removes any app you drag onto it, and offers to clear leftovers when you trash an app yourself. Apps and their files go onto the Undo Shelf for 7 days; an app that’s open, or one that comes with macOS, is left alone.

Download SiftMac · scanning is free, and so is your first 2 GB of cleaning · See how it works