# BuhoCleaner vs CleanMyMac: the budget toolbox and the big all-in-one

Compare · Checked 20 November 2026 · Updated 21 November 2026. By Mohit Nippanikar, who makes SiftMac.

## The short answer

- **Choose BuhoCleaner** for a low price with a lifetime licence ($25.99 for one Mac when checked), a trial that removes up to 3 GB, and support back to macOS 10.10.
- **Choose CleanMyMac** for a larger toolset with malware removal, Space Lens, Cloud Cleanup and AI-tool cleanup, from $3.33 a month on the yearly plan, or a one-time licence.
- **Both** offer a 30-day money-back guarantee, and neither describes a way to restore what it deletes.

## 1. BuhoCleaner and CleanMyMac side by side

Taken from drbuho.com, cleanmymac.com and MacPaw’s store and help pages on 20 November 2026. BuhoCleaner’s prices were shown as Black Friday discounts.

|  | BuhoCleaner | CleanMyMac |
| --- | --- | --- |
| **Price** | $17.99 a year or $25.99 lifetime for 1 Mac (shown against $39.99 and $67.99); 10 Macs lifetime $69.99 | Yearly plan from $3.33 a month for 1 Mac; monthly and one-time licences too |
| **Model** | Yearly subscription or lifetime licence | Yearly or monthly subscription, or one-time licence |
| **Free to try** | Trial removes up to 3 GB of files | 7-day free trial |
| **Refunds** | 30-day money-back guarantee | 30-day money-back guarantee |
| **What it does** | Flash Clean, uninstaller with leftovers, large and duplicate files, similar photos, disk analyzer, startup items, RAM, menu bar monitor, Xcode cache cleaner, file shredder, DNS flush, Spotlight reindex | Cleanup including AI-tool clutter, malware removal, maintenance tasks, uninstaller and updater, duplicates and similar images, Space Lens, Cloud Cleanup |
| **How it deletes** | Not described, except the shredder, which makes files unrecoverable | Bypasses the Trash for large and old files and duplicates, per its help pages |
| **Undo** | Not described | Not described in its help |
| **Explains items** | Not described | Smart Insights, where Apple Intelligence runs (Apple silicon, macOS 26) |
| **macOS** | 10.10 to macOS 27, Intel and Apple silicon | 11 or later |
| **Where to buy** | drbuho.com | MacPaw Store, Setapp, Mac App Store |
| **Made by** | Dr.Buho | MacPaw |

## 2. The main differences

### Paying once or every year

BuhoCleaner’s lifetime licence is one payment, $25.99 for one Mac when checked, with a yearly plan as the alternative. CleanMyMac’s cheapest entry is a yearly subscription, about $40 a year at $3.33 a month, though MacPaw also sells a one-time licence for each plan size. BuhoCleaner’s store presents its prices as large discounts under a countdown, so compare what you’d actually pay.

### How much each app covers

CleanMyMac reaches further: it removes malware, cleans out iCloud Drive, Google Drive, OneDrive and Dropbox, lists AI-tool clutter and local models, updates apps, and has privacy tools for browsers. BuhoCleaner covers the everyday cleanup and adds a menu bar monitor (CPU load and temperature, fan speed, RAM and network), an Xcode cache cleaner and a file shredder.

### Older Macs

BuhoCleaner runs on macOS 10.10 and later, up to macOS 27, on Intel and Apple silicon. The current CleanMyMac needs macOS 11 or later, so on an older Mac BuhoCleaner may be the one that installs.

### What happens to deleted files

MacPaw states that large and old files and duplicates are deleted permanently, bypassing the Trash; Photos library duplicates go to Recently Deleted. BuhoCleaner’s guides don’t say where cleaned files go, apart from the shredder, whose guide says shredded files can’t be retrieved from the Trash or with recovery tools. With either app, a Time Machine backup before a big clean is sensible.

## 3. Which to choose

### Pick BuhoCleaner if

- you want to pay once, and as little as possible;
- your Mac runs a macOS older than 11;
- you like a menu bar monitor and a shredder in the same app.

### Pick CleanMyMac if

- you want malware removal and maintenance tasks alongside cleanup;
- you keep files in iCloud Drive, Google Drive, OneDrive or Dropbox and want those cleaned too;
- you’d like explanations from Smart Insights on an Apple silicon Mac with macOS 26.

Neither is built around an undo. If that matters most, the [BuhoCleaner alternatives](https://siftmac.com/alternatives/buhocleaner) page covers apps that keep deleted items for a while.

## Questions

### Is BuhoCleaner’s lifetime licence really one payment?

Its store describes the Lifetime Plan as pay once, with no recurring fees, and its trial guide says a purchased licence includes free upgrades for life. The yearly plan is the subscription option.

### Which has the better free trial?

They work differently. BuhoCleaner’s trial lets you remove up to 3 GB of files and use many of its tools, such as finding large and duplicate files and freeing RAM. CleanMyMac gives you 7 days, and its FAQ says the free version lets you test all of its features.

### Does BuhoCleaner scan for malware?

Malware removal isn’t among BuhoCleaner’s listed features. CleanMyMac includes it, and macOS has its own XProtect.

### Can I get CleanMyMac cheaper if I already use BuhoCleaner?

MacPaw’s store offers CleanMyMac at 40% off if you use another Mac cleaner or antivirus; you request it from the store page.

## How SiftMac handles it

SiftMac is the third option if space is all you need and you want a way back: a verdict and a reason for every item, nothing in use touched, and 7 days on the Undo Shelf for downloads, apps, duplicates and the Trash. $12 once for the first 100 buyers, then $19 for 2 Macs; macOS 14 or later.

Download: https://siftmac.com/SiftMac.dmg (scanning is free, and so is the first 2 GB of cleaning).

## Sources

- [Dr.Buho store: BuhoCleaner yearly, lifetime and business plans](https://www.drbuho.com/black-friday-sale)
- [Dr.Buho: BuhoCleaner features](https://www.drbuho.com/buhocleaner)
- [BuhoCleaner guide: the free trial](https://www.drbuho.com/buhocleaner/guide/trial)
- [BuhoCleaner guide: shredding files](https://www.drbuho.com/buhocleaner/guide/shred-file)
- [BuhoCleaner download: requirements and version](https://www.drbuho.com/buhocleaner/download)
- [CleanMyMac by MacPaw: tools, trial, requirements](https://cleanmymac.com/)
- [MacPaw store: CleanMyMac plans and competitor discount](https://macpaw.com/store/cleanmymac)
- [MacPaw: Feature availability across CleanMyMac editions](https://macpaw.com/support/cleanmymac/knowledgebase/missing-features)
- [MacPaw: Manage large and old files with CleanMyMac](https://macpaw.com/support/cleanmymac/knowledgebase/large-and-old)

## Related

- [BuhoCleaner alternatives: paid, free, and when to keep it](https://siftmac.com/alternatives/buhocleaner)
- [CleanMyMac alternatives: free options, and one that explains every file](https://siftmac.com/compare/cleanmymac-alternative)
- [How to cancel CleanMyMac, get a refund, and remove it from your Mac](https://siftmac.com/guides/cancel-cleanmymac)
- [CleanMyMac vs CCleaner for Mac: a big toolkit or a lighter cleaner](https://siftmac.com/compare/cleanmymac-vs-ccleaner)

Canonical: https://siftmac.com/compare/buhocleaner-vs-cleanmymac
